The Federal Communications Commission (FCC) has proposed a $6 million fine for a scammer who used voice-cloning technology to impersonate President Biden in a series of illegal robocalls during the New Hampshire primary election. This case, although centered on robocalls, serves as a stark warning to other potential high-tech scammers.
In January, many voters in New Hampshire received calls that falsely appeared to be from President Biden, urging them not to vote in the upcoming primary. In recent years, technology has increasingly made it accessible to create a voice clone of President Biden, enabling the deceptive tactic.
The Technology: Generative AI and Voice Cloning
Voice-cloning technology, especially through generative AI platforms, has made it relatively easy to produce convincing fake voices. Numerous services now offer voice cloning with minimal restrictions, making it simple to create a Biden-like voice using just a few minutes of his publicly available speeches.
The FCC and several law enforcement agencies have made it clear that they strictly prohibit using such technology to deceive and manipulate voters. Robocalls themselves are illegal under certain circumstances, and using AI-generated voices in this manner compounds the violation.
Loyaan Egal, chief of the FCC’s Enforcement Bureau, emphasized the agency’s commitment to addressing this misuse of technology: “We will act swiftly and decisively to ensure that bad actors cannot use U.S. telecommunications networks to facilitate the misuse of generative AI technology to interfere with elections, defraud consumers, or compromise sensitive data.”
The Perpetrators: Steve Kramer and Associates
The primary individual behind these robocalls was “political consultant” Steve Kramer, who collaborated with Life Corporation, a company previously charged with illegal robocalls, and the telecom service provider Lingo. Lingo operates under various names, including Americatel, BullsEyeComm, Clear Choice Communications, Excel Telecommunications, Impact Telecom, Matrix Business Technologies, Startec Global Communications, Trinsic Communications, and VarTec Telecom.
Kramer is reportedly in violation of several regulations, but as of now, there are no criminal charges against him or his associates. The FCC’s ability to impose penalties is limited; they must work in conjunction with local or federal law enforcement to enforce their determinations.
The Fine and Future Actions
The proposed $6 million fine represents a significant penalty, but authorities often reduce the actual amount paid for various reasons. Despite this, it underscores the seriousness of the offense. Kramer will have the opportunity to respond to the allegations, while separate actions are being taken against Lingo, which may result in additional fines or the loss of licenses.
Following this incident, the FCC officially declared that using AI-generated voices in robocalls is illegal. In February, prompted by the question of whether these voices fall under the category of “artificial,” the FCC sensibly concluded that they do, making this decision.
This case highlights the growing challenges posed by advances in AI technology, particularly in the realm of voice cloning. It also demonstrates the regulatory efforts needed to prevent the misuse of such technologies in ways that can undermine democratic processes and harm individuals. As AI continues to evolve, it is likely that regulatory frameworks will need to adapt continually to address new and emerging threats.
See also: Patronus AI Remarkable Debut: LLM Governance Tool Gains Momentum
