In a series of posts on X (formerly known as Twitter) on Thursday, Paul Graham, co-founder of Y Combinator, addressed rumors surrounding Sam Altman’s departure from the startup accelerator. Paul Graham contradicted claims that Y Combinator forced Sam Altman to resign as president in 2019 due to conflicts of interest.
Sam Altman joined Y Combinator as a part-time partner in 2011. By February 2014, Graham had appointed him as president of the accelerator. Altman’s tenure saw significant milestones, including the launch of OpenAI in 2015, a nonprofit initiative co-founded with notable figures like Elon Musk and Peter Thiel, which raised $1 billion.
Balancing Y Combinator and OpenAI
For several years, Altman managed responsibilities at both Y Combinator and OpenAI. However, this dual role came into question in 2019 when OpenAI decided to create a for-profit subsidiary with Altman as CEO. According to Graham, Y Combinator’s founding partner Jessica Livingston told Altman that he needed to choose between his commitments.
Graham explained that if Altman had chosen to focus entirely on Y Combinator, they would have supported that decision. Instead, Altman agreed it was best for Y Combinator to find a new president if he was to dedicate himself fully to OpenAI.
Graham challenged reports suggesting that Y Combinator ousted Altman for prioritizing personal projects over his role. A Washington Post article previously reported that Graham cut short an overseas trip to personally inform Altman of his dismissal.
Helen Toner, a former OpenAI board member, has also made claims about the true reasons behind Altman’s exit from Y Combinator. Speaking on the Ted AI Show podcast, she suggested that the details were intentionally kept quiet at the time.
Conflict of Interest Concerns
Reports indicated that some Y Combinator partners were concerned about Altman’s indirect stake in OpenAI. Y Combinator had invested $10 million in OpenAI’s for-profit arm, raising questions about potential conflicts of interest. However, Graham clarified that this investment occurred before Altman was fully committed to OpenAI and that he was unaware of it.
Graham’s posts coincided with an op-ed in The Economist by OpenAI board members Bret Taylor and Larry Summers. The piece defended Altman against accusations from former board members Helen Toner and Tasha McCauley, who argued that Altman could not be trusted to resist profit-driven pressures.
Future of OpenAI
Despite these controversies, Altman is reportedly considering transforming OpenAI into a for-profit corporation. This move is driven by investor pressures, particularly from Microsoft, to focus more on commercial projects.
Paul Graham’s recent statements aim to set the record straight regarding Sam Altman’s departure from Y Combinator. While conflicting reports and opinions persist, Graham’s narrative emphasizes a mutual agreement rather than a forced resignation.
See also: EthonAI The AI Manufacturing Startup Secures $16.5M
